So I’ve been trying seriously to write a novel now for almost 7 years. It was an on and off thing until i got older, got a job and made a serious block of time for it daily. I've been on this forum since I was around 18! I am now 32. time flies! I've grown up and learned a lot about the world and the novel I started in my 20's has expanded and changed quite a lot.. I finally broke through and wrote a couple chapters until I hit a large plot hole and went back to the drawing board but I fixed that recently and am moving forward again.
I know 70% of my plot and I’m almost there! For me it has been about plotting and plotting. I fear pantsering even now...
Recently, on a Facebook group a person reached out to me and asked if I would be interested in having a writing coach. The first session would be free. I figured it couldn’t hurt. Why not?
So she set me up with a woman who has written and published two books. I was hoping to hear about her writing process. Unfortunately I walked away from the meeting feeling a bit disheartened.
Within 10 minutes, I could tell something was wrong. I must’ve rubbed her the wrong way. I know I mentioned some books that I liked and disliked. Perhaps one of the ones I disliked was special to her. Regardless she began by saying that my book cannot fall into the two categories it is currently in. Fantasy and Sci-fi. Every so often as she spoke she would give a high shrill laugh with her eyes closed and shake her head as if, "heres another aspiring author idiot. Just like the rest of them..."
My book takes place in a futuristic setting, however some people still use magic, an old form of technology. she said there wont be readers for that. It's either sci-fi or fantasy not really both. I argued that all the mainstream stories out there combine the two a lot. Star wars has the force, Marvel movies are big and they are basically futuristic heroes with powers. I'm quite sure my story will find an audience. I set out to write a book that I would want to read, and I enjoy the mainstream stories out there. My goal is to write a good story and then worry about those things afterwards. Besides I am quite sure fantasy and sci-fi is "writing to market" as she says.
Then I told her I have 3 point of views. This upset her greatly. Again she laughed and made a dirty face like I had let a turd simply drop out of my backside. She said I should stick with one point of view as a beginner writer. I'm not exactly about to change my whole book because I am a beginner. All the characters are important at this point. It should be noted that while I have 3 points of view, I have one main character. the other point of views are secondary and only have a few chapters each.
The three point of views are: my protagonist, a kidnapped girl, and the antagonist's sidekick. The sidekick is only 2-3 chapters and lets us have a glimpse of what the antagonist is up to. Sort of teaser chapters. One in the prologue and two others later on. The kidnapped girl came about on its own and she has a small story arc thats quite exciting. I liked the game of thrones books because of the idea of having a few main characters, but I found it difficult to know who to root for. In my book there is a clear protagonist with some side characters weaved in. I was happy.
Then she discussed how my book MUST follow the three act structure. I'm not sure it does. Every story has a beginning, middle and end. However I found that trying to stick to a rigid format made the book seem stale and forced. For me it's about creating conflict as soon as possible and adding fuel to the fire as we go. Eventually everything will get resolved in the end. In hindsight maybe the book will fall into a three act structure, however I am not thinking about that and I can't see some of my favorite books working that way. I also read books on writing (Stephen kings, and a few others) and I like watching Brandon Sanderson clips on youtube. I find myself agreeing a lot with the things he says and he doesn't say you need to follow anything rigidly.
At some point she just began to shake her head "no" for the remainder of the zoom call. Her face said "this call was a mistake and a waste of my time." :/
She asked me if I would be traditionally publishing or self publishing and I said I have not gotten there yet. However I graduated in graphic design and know how to use inDesign seriously so I might give self publishing a try. I also know where I can hire some illustrators for the cover.
At this she almost died of laughter as she bounced up and down on her chair that squeaked away in agreement. The very idea of me trying to self publish! Now there's a good laugh!
"Sweety! If you want to be part of the professional world of writing you better hire someone to do the publishing for you. You can self publish, but please hire a professional. I'm just trying to help you here." She said, her face full of sadness and sympathy. "You don't want your book and cover to look like what I see in those... those silly forums and facebook groups!"
She has not read a word of my book. All I did was tell her what it's about. She seems to think it sounded ok, although her face was telling a very different story.
I may have animated her a bit more than she really was in the text
.
So am I crazy? Should I be removing some characters and change the story? Am I trying to fly before I can walk or something? Is it bad to have magic and science mixed? Can I self publish? Why am I suddenly doubting my entire book....