Horcruxes. The remaining.

Joel007 said:
If I'd made a horcrux... I'd probably magic it into the surface of the moon.

Get rid of that one, suckers!
Click to expand...
LOL... I think it would be easier being a witch, I mean good grief they made a flying car so what would it be to get to the moon? ;)
 
I was thinking so big that in order to remove it the entire world would notice. So in order to keep it a secret they wouldn't be able to get rid of it, even if they could find it. What spotty little kid is going to stumble onto a horcrux transfigured into a moon crater anyway?
 
Really? I never imagined you as a spotty little kid.

I'll have to come up with a new plan now that i've shared that one... we evil villains just can't keep our secret plans secret.
 
Yeah that's what i thought... but perhaps he wants 7 soul pieces, in which case his own personal wee soul would count.
 
MJRevell said:
Well, we are all entitled to our own opinions. I am inclined to believe mine here, until you can provide any evidence to the contrary.
Click to expand...

And I, mine. And I will wait for the day when JK Rowling says that I'm right and you're wrong :p (I warn you though, I will gloat.)

MJRevell said:
Actually, yes you said his scar was a horcrux - which in my opinion is the same as saying Harry is one.
Click to expand...

Well, then the answer is NO. It's not the same, and you have to get over this because it's what confuses you.

MJRevell said:
It's the same argument, it goes hand in hand -
Click to expand...

No it doesn't. You're just insisting it does to support your argument. But really, it doesn't. Apples and Oranges. Onions and Tomatoes.

MJRevell said:
I can see that, as in most Harry is a horcrux cases, the argument will not be settled.
Click to expand...

Oh it will be, on July 2007, when JK Releases the last book.
 
Oh boy. I am not confused in the slightest - simply curious. How can you possibly say that Harry or his scar being a horcrux are different theories? It's exactly the same theory; that something about, or in Harry is a horcrux - that it was created accidentally, and that he, Harry, will have to get rid of it before he vanquishes Voldemort.

On a side note: his scar is not a little containing object hanging on his head like a glass; it is part of him. If anything, it is a mark to show that he does indeed have some of Voldemorts soul in him, and it may well vanish if he removes the soul fragment.

We are agreed on one thing, i believe: if Harry has some Voldysoul in him, it was an accident. Harry didn't have the scar before the incident, so how can it, in itself contain a fragment of soul? How can it, in itself be a horcrux?

That's like saying: "I'm going to make a horcrux with this kettle. But, wait for it, will put my bit of soul right in that little bobble at the top of the lid!" It probably isn't even possible to get that specific when making horcruxes. Otherwise Voldemort no doubt would have put his soul in the last page of his diary, or Nagini's eye, so even if she dies, he can keep the eye, and his soul, safe.

Plus, Voldemort - though cunning - would have had to devise the rather far-fetched plan of creating a scar from scratch, placing it on Harry's head, and then putting some soul in it.

But for the sake of discussion, let's say this theory is correct; that Harry, or, if you insist, his scar, has a piece of Voldemort's soul in him. How, exactly, did it get there?

I think i remember you (or perhaps someone else) posting something about Voldemort's soul leaving his body, after the AK backfired on him, and that, because it was split, one piece sought out Harry, and the other ran away. Do you still believe this? Because, i doubt very much a little piece of soul would seek out a body, and if it did it would be more possession than horcrux. And if this scenario did occur, then his soul would surely split into (at least) two other pieces - which would, on this logic, seek out a further two objects?

I think it is entirely plausible for Harry to be a horcrux - i can see both sides of the argument. I just don't think it will happen. In any case, i look forward to your (possible) gloating :p I can't promise any gloating if my assumptions end up being correct - but it will be interesting.
 
Out of curiosity - how do the deatheaters get their marks?
Presumablly Volde has some way of creating a magical mark like that, perhaps Harry's scar is something similar?
 
I doubt that rowling will ever deign to explain every little quirky detail. Unless there's loads of money in it :)

Perhaps he who must not be named (not to be confused with he who must not be sneezed at) was less restricted in his research of new spells by his lack of conscience, and consequently was able to make spells no other wizard wanted to, or dared to, attempt
 
MJRevell said:
Oh boy. I am not confused in the slightest - simply curious. How can you possibly say that Harry or his scar being a horcrux are different theories?
Click to expand...

It's different. Harry cannot be a Horcrux because his soul is still inside his body -- one soul per body only! Which is why I believe that Quirrell is also NOT a Horcrux, and that Nagini is also NOT a horcrux. Because they still have their own souls inside their bodies.

Harry's scar is different. It is actually not part of him since it does not heal; any wound inflicted upon you, magical or not, should heal because of the natural ability of our bodies to heal itself. I know this is the same even the Potter Universe because he has gotten into many other frightful things, got himself bruised and those things healed. The scar on his hand from Umbridge's torture healed into a white scar.

So yeah, YOU ARE CONFUSED, and you just don't want to admit it, because you know I'm correct. :p

MJRevell said:
It's exactly the same theory; that something about, or in Harry is a horcrux - that it was created accidentally, and that he, Harry, will have to get rid of it before he vanquishes Voldemort.

On a side note: his scar is not a little containing object hanging on his head like a glass; it is part of him. If anything, it is a mark to show that he does indeed have some of Voldemorts soul in him, and it may well vanish if he removes the soul fragment.

We are agreed on one thing, i believe: if Harry has some Voldysoul in him, it was an accident. Harry didn't have the scar before the incident, so how can it, in itself contain a fragment of soul? How can it, in itself be a horcrux?

That's like saying: "I'm going to make a horcrux with this kettle. But, wait for it, will put my bit of soul right in that little bobble at the top of the lid!" It probably isn't even possible to get that specific when making horcruxes. Otherwise Voldemort no doubt would have put his soul in the last page of his diary, or Nagini's eye, so even if she dies, he can keep the eye, and his soul, safe.

Plus, Voldemort - though cunning - would have had to devise the rather far-fetched plan of creating a scar from scratch, placing it on Harry's head, and then putting some soul in it.

But for the sake of discussion, let's say this theory is correct; that Harry, or, if you insist, his scar, has a piece of Voldemort's soul in him. How, exactly, did it get there?

I think i remember you (or perhaps someone else) posting something about Voldemort's soul leaving his body, after the AK backfired on him, and that, because it was split, one piece sought out Harry, and the other ran away. Do you still believe this?
Click to expand...

This whole thing shows how confused you are about Horcruxes in general. And no I wasn't the one that said that. Good theory though.

MJRevell said:
Because, i doubt very much a little piece of soul would seek out a body, and if it did it would be more possession than horcrux. And if this scenario did occur, then his soul would surely split into (at least) two other pieces - which would, on this logic, seek out a further two objects?

I think it is entirely plausible for Harry to be a horcrux - i can see both sides of the argument. I just don't think it will happen. In any case, i look forward to your (possible) gloating :p I can't promise any gloating if my assumptions end up being correct - but it will be interesting.
Click to expand...

You bet! I will gloat, and you better be ready for it. I gloated in all the HP forums when JK dropped the bomb that Ron stays with Hermione, Harry goes with Ginny, and Dumbledore ends up dead. Yeah, those were my theories before HBP came out, and they all came true.

If my theories end up wrong, then I will not gloat, but I seriously doubt your theories are correct. There are too many loopholes in your theories.

So yeah, I will gloat! :D
 
Jees this thread has turned into one that is trying to determain what part of Harry or if he is at all, a horcrux.
 
I keep hearing the harry potter is one rumour to, but i think that majimaune's list is probably correct.

Majimaune said:
  1. Slytherins ring (destroyed)
  2. The diary (destroyed)
  3. Slytherins locket (destroyed)
  4. Hufflepuff's cup
  5. Something of Ravenclaw's
  6. Voldemorts snake
  7. Voldie himself.
The is nothing there of Griffindors because the only known things left are the Sorting Hat and the Sword.
Click to expand...
 
edott said:
I keep hearing the harry potter is one rumour to, but i think that majimaune's list is probably correct.
Click to expand...

Is probably correct...though Nagini is not in my list, I don't close my doors on that possibility but there is just too many things against it.
 
At the end of the half blodded prince a note is found in the locket that dumbledore and harry go to get. the note is from r.a.b i think. i think this is siris' brother who he mentions in the order of the phoenix. also when cleaning out grimmauld place they find a locket that they could not open in a cupboard i think this is the missing horcrux that should have been in the cave.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
F Human colony secretly develops interstellar travel and hides in another star system while the remaining humans try to develop it and find them Book Search 4
Extollager Remaining Unpublished Tolkien Works; Rare Poem Link JRR Tolkien 1
P Not all the remaining passengers on the Titanic were afraid of dying Book Discussion 20

Similar threads


Back
Top