Re: The Scariest Movie Ever!
When I was a kid, whenever we went to the video store, I'd always be inexplicably drawn to the horror section and scare myself by looking at the covers, one was The Blob 1980's version it'd creep me out, with the person trapped in the blob on the front cover. When I was about 7 I saw the trailer for IT and it freaked me out. I have OCD and a lot of it after that was connected to red eyes and clowns and drains, took me years to get past it. When I was 16, I watched Basketcase and that really scared me, I was terrified that Belial was going to find out where I lived and get me. For about a fortnight, I had to sleep with a baseball bat in my bed, check all over my room before I went to bed to make sure he wasn't hiding there already and leave a light on. I have a very overactive imagination!! A couple of years ago, I watched Sister, My Sister and was chilled by it and that it's a true story. Turn of the Screw is unsettling as well. Funnily enough, I'm a huge horror fan.
My husband got creeped out by The Mothman Prophecies, we watched the doco about the myth where people claimed to have seen it and have it hang around their house and he was a bit wary of red lights at night for a little while after that.