The Revived Tolkien Trivia

Do you mean porter? That, to me, is not synonymous with stout, as the two, though coloured similarly, are not at all the same.

Well, someone at Wiki disagrees:

While there is a great deal of disagreement in the brewing world on this subject, at one time, porter was considered an alternative name for stout. It was originally used in the 18th century. Historically, there are no differences between stout and porter, though there has been a tendency for breweries to differentiate the strengths of their dark beers with the words "extra", "double" and "stout". The term "stout" was initially used to indicate a stronger porter than other porters issued by an individual brewery — though one brewery's porter could easily be stronger than a neighbouring brewery's stout. Though not consistent, this is the usage that was most commonly employed

(Though it does say "a great deal of disagreement", and it is talking about historcal usage rather than modern, so you could be right too)

Here's the page:

Stout - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia


I know of no instance of "porter" in Tolkien.

Well, if you can find one, the next question is yours! :)
 
Well, seeing as you've practically had to nose-lead us, HB...

It is porter, and it's some of the Dwarves at the Unexpected Party that ask for it - it's not possible to be more specific apart from it not being Bifur, Bofur, Bombur or Thorin, as they arrive after it's asked for.

Already it had almost become a throng. Some called for ale, and some for porter, and one for coffee, and all of them for cakes; so the hobbit was kept very busy for a while.

The Hobbit - Chapter 1 - An Unexpected Party.
 
Ding-dong-a-ling-dang! (As I believe Bilbo's bell went at the time)

Also I believe the only mention of coffee in the Middle-Earth stories.

Over to you, your squidliness
 
Not quite the only mention, because the next sentence starts "A big jug of coffee had just been set down in the hearth..."
But only a real pedant would quibble....:D


Right....

What/who will wander witless?
 
I know it, but don't have the books to quote here at university... Here's hoping no-one knows anything about insects :D
 
I think Wordsworth said it best:

I'll wander witless as some ants
Who, when their queen dies, **** their pants





(Ah, it feels good to shed the guise of the sophisticate)
 
Gah - rules merchants.:p

"As when death smites the swollen brooding thing that inhabits their crawling hill and holds them all in sway, ants will wander witless and purposeless and then feebly die ..."

LOTR, Book VI, ch4 "The Field of Cormallen"
 
Now, now: Dura lex, sed lex

You to go, after carefully putting down this bell....:D
 
Right, here I will try to make amends for my previous debatable question.

And the question is, what/who/where is called "debatable"?
 
South Gondor?
According to the Map.______
 

Attachments

  • map.JPG
    map.JPG
    35 KB · Views: 139
Famine or feast, this thread...

Umm...
Where would I find nice dull plain gold wall-hangings?
 
In a house in Minas Tirith, close to the wall of the citadel on the north side:

"he showed them to a fair room, light and airy, with goodly hangings of dull gold sheen unfigured."

LOTR, Book V, Ch1, "Minas Tirith"
 
We'll have to slow down - the local foundry's running out of stock...

Ding...
 
Slow down? This is my friday night social life! I'm livin it large!

But yes, my quote-miners are muttering darkly about overwork.

Anyway, here's my question. What/who could one be sentenced to death merely for looking upon?
 
The pool of Henneth Annûn in Northern Ithilien, refuge of Faramir and the men of Gondor harrying the gathering armies of Mordor.

"The price is not set on the fish," said Faramir. "Only to come here and look on the pool bears the penalty of death."

TT - Book IV - Chapter VI - The Forbidden Pool
 
Mercy Buckups!

There are only three examples of words from the Black Speech in LotR.
  • Can you reference all three?
  • Bonus point for finding where the above paraphrase comes from!
 

Similar threads


Back
Top