Discussion -- 300 Word Challenge #3

Status
Not open for further replies.
Re: Discussion thread -- Three Hundred Word Writing Challenge #3

yes, and its just as hard to learn how to cry again after you learn how not to.
 
Re: Discussion thread -- Three Hundred Word Writing Challenge #3

Hoopy – I was not wholly sure how to interpret this one by Hoops, it was oblique enough to give a couple of different interpretations, to me at least, and I think that is why I liked it so much. Was it playing with our time-sense, so that the eternity that is suggested at the start might actually only be minutes to the human view of time, or was it something more supernatural, someone being reborn into different forms, each time getting closer to the revenge they seek, locked in a void waiting rebirth. It’s more likely to be the latter, but as is quite often the case it is the end of the story that really makes it. A wry smile, and a great little piece of writing.

Chris – I think the thing that struck me first with Chris’s story was the imagery he used. The description of a village – people and animals transformed to stone is one that really stood out to me, filling my mind with a powerful image that was truly sealed with the mention of a stone robin. The story itself had an innate beauty to it, a mournful echo of loss and helplessness; someone powerful enough to facedown death outwitted by a form that was neither life or dissolution. A prisoner of stone, mute testament to the capriciousness of ancient gods. (and a lizard lady with snakes on her head).

Ökuþórr – I really did not know what to make of this one when I started to read it, but as the story unfolded it just got – I don’t know – amazing I guess. It is another example of the quality and diversity of the challenge entries. There is a certain epic feel to, the overthrow of society by the descending angels, revealed not to be benevolent as has been written, but vicious, powerful and malevolent more than happy to inflict attempted genocide an entire race. But then the almost pathetic fight back added more to the story, a man’s attempt to do what damage he could, seemed to round the story off nicely, but it was concluded even more strongly – the idea that the statues could have been the good ones, imprisoned in stone... great story.

Alchemist – I’d seen what other people had written about this one before I read it, so my curiosity was piqued. Damn it, Alchemist you made another adult cry, but enough about Mrs Perp. Even I was touched. What a great interpretation, the opening moments of a parent’s loss were almost tangible and a worthy piece of writing in their own right. But the end of the story really underlined it, very well handled and worded perfectly. Two heart punches in one piece, jaw dropping nearly. Excellent. Can’t say much more than that can I?

Parson – I was very interested to see how our resident Parson would handle the story this time round and I was not disappointed. A splendid tale, with a strong moral centre and a great story wrapped around it. As is often the case with our challenges certain lines really spring out at me, making the whole story a thing of beauty and that certainly happened here. I just loved the construction of the last line. It seemed an almost perfect capstone to another excellent tale.
 
Re: Discussion thread -- Three Hundred Word Writing Challenge #3

I finally managed to submit an entry. I'm not totally happy with it, but it's there!

Now it's time to get on with the extremely difficult task of choosing a 75 word story to vote for...
 
Re: Discussion thread -- Three Hundred Word Writing Challenge #3

Sneaky Mith, waiting until I posted my comments and then sneaking the entry in...

Mith – Much as I said with Parson’s sometimes there is a line that seems quite exquisite in its own right, and the second line here serves that purpose, for me at least. At the star I felt there were a few repetitive words, but upon second reading I really felt that they added to the piece when I looked at it as a whole – knowing the outcome as it were. The impression of a sad, lonely figure coming to end her life is a potent and powerful one, given the twist as she is drawn from life into the angel. The final line really seals the story nicely, a friend, lover or husband lost and asking the question why, is one of the most terrible aspects of suicide, and for the deceased to watch that pain is perhaps a lesson to be learned, unfortunately for most, it is too late.
 
Re: Discussion thread -- Three Hundred Word Writing Challenge #3

I admit it, I just wanted the glory of single post review of my entry :D

Thank you for that review, makes your day when something you've struggled with gets a positive look at. I struggled with this, once I'd chosen my subject matter it was a bit harder to put into words than I realised.
 
Re: Discussion thread -- Three Hundred Word Writing Challenge #3

Hoopy – I was not wholly sure how to interpret this one by Hoops, it was oblique enough to give a couple of different interpretations, to me at least, and I think that is why I liked it so much. Was it playing with our time-sense, so that the eternity that is suggested at the start might actually only be minutes to the human view of time, or was it something more supernatural, someone being reborn into different forms, each time getting closer to the revenge they seek, locked in a void waiting rebirth. It’s more likely to be the latter, but as is quite often the case it is the end of the story that really makes it. A wry smile, and a great little piece of writing.

Mostly it was my being my sadistic self and enjoying the idea of someone so full of it waiting so long, just to get squished. Muahaha.

Although when I originally thought of the idea, it was through contemplating the long voids on either side of the brief span of life.

Thanks for the kind words, as always!
 
Re: Discussion thread -- Three Hundred Word Writing Challenge #3

Parson – I was very interested to see how our resident Parson would handle the story this time round and I was not disappointed. A splendid tale, with a strong moral centre and a great story wrapped around it. As is often the case with our challenges certain lines really spring out at me, making the whole story a thing of beauty and that certainly happened here. I just loved the construction of the last line. It seemed an almost perfect capstone to another excellent tale.

As always Perp, most kind, most insightful, and the idea of your looking forward to my story sends goose bumps up my spine.
 
Re: Discussion thread -- Three Hundred Word Writing Challenge #3

Alchemist – I’d seen what other people had written about this one before I read it, so my curiosity was piqued. Damn it, Alchemist you made another adult cry, but enough about Mrs Perp. Even I was touched. What a great interpretation, the opening moments of a parent’s loss were almost tangible and a worthy piece of writing in their own right. But the end of the story really underlined it, very well handled and worded perfectly. Two heart punches in one piece, jaw dropping nearly. Excellent. Can’t say much more than that can I?

Indeed, no. I'm almost blushing. Thanks!
 
Re: Discussion thread -- Three Hundred Word Writing Challenge #3

Well, I have writ me story. But I'm letting it stew for a day or so before posting, as I'm not at all happy with it.

Something strange I've noticed, though, is that I'm writing more of the Challenge pieces in present tense, which is something I wouldn't dream of doing ordinarily. And in first person! I have no idea why that should be.


Anyway, I see we're lacking a fair few entries at present. Only four and a bit days to go, folks. Let's get writing.
 
Re: Discussion thread -- Three Hundred Word Writing Challenge #3

Arrrghhh stress!

I've had a few ideas but none of them have really worked out yet. And I want this to be a good one, because the pic demands it.


...and here comes another idea.
 
Re: Discussion thread -- Three Hundred Word Writing Challenge #3


Ökuþórr
– I really did not know what to make of this one when I started to read it, but as the story unfolded it just got – I don’t know – amazing I guess. It is another example of the quality and diversity of the challenge entries. There is a certain epic feel to, the overthrow of society by the descending angels, revealed not to be benevolent as has been written, but vicious, powerful and malevolent more than happy to inflict attempted genocide an entire race. But then the almost pathetic fight back added more to the story, a man’s attempt to do what damage he could, seemed to round the story off nicely, but it was concluded even more strongly – the idea that the statues could have been the good ones, imprisoned in stone... great story.

Thank you for another great review Perp. :D
 
Re: Discussion thread -- Three Hundred Word Writing Challenge #3

Ashcroft I liked it, gave me chills, made me thing.
:)
 
Re: Discussion thread -- Three Hundred Word Writing Challenge #3

Moonbat has given an interesting twist on the subject matter. It's a deeper story than one might think at the start, delicately sliding inward as it rolls on, a twist at the end that, while perhaps foreseeable, I feel wraps it up well nonetheless. Kind a shot at self-mockery but in a darkly humorous way, and above all, the entry shows that even the purest of beings cannot escape the dark feelings of resentment and loathing.


Ashcroft has given a nice premonition piece for us, a tragically sweet story about one guardian's duty to the one she watches over, sworn to take it even beyond life into death. It is one that inspires chills, and can actually wrap up both of this month's challenges into one, conjuring dark images of possible futures for us all, keeping us awake at night for fear of losing ourselves at any moment. A proud entry for the fast-approaching All Hallow's Eve.
 
Re: Discussion thread -- Three Hundred Word Writing Challenge #3

Oh, thanks for the kind words guys (or girls? At the very least I know that hope is a girl!)!

I'll endeavour to actually formulate some written responses to the entries once it's all wrapped up. I've read them all already and I've, by and large, been thoroughly impressed. The writing ability of the people on this site is far above average.

Good work, everyone who entered, and thanks, everyone who's read the stuff.
 
Re: Discussion thread -- Three Hundred Word Writing Challenge #3

Neither will I, Ash, neither will I. :D


(And to be perfectly honest, my favorite Kirby game is Nightmare in Dreamland. :D)



Actually, I am starting to seriously think about stealing Perp's ideas about reviewing these stories that come up. Sometimes what I say in passing is just not strong enough to convey how I felt about a story-alchemist's entry for the 300 this time around is a good example of that.
 
Re: Discussion thread -- Three Hundred Word Writing Challenge #3

Actually, I am starting to seriously think about stealing Perp's ideas about reviewing these stories that come up. Sometimes what I say in passing is just not strong enough to convey how I felt about a story-alchemist's entry for the 300 this time around is a good example of that.

Go for it. I'm sure as heck going to nick that idea and write some mini-reviews once the submissions deadline has finished.

Out of interest, do you know what Percival wrote to get himself an infraction? Or might it be best to not repeat it? It's tough to know how to proceed at these junctions, because I'd like to know what he did (so that I don't repeat the mistake), but if it was anything genuinely malicious then it'd obviously be better to just let it fizzle away.
 
Re: Discussion thread -- Three Hundred Word Writing Challenge #3

You know, I can't remember and from Dave's message about the reason behind it I feel it's best to keep it that way. The words "thinly veiled" usually mean that such a thing was an attempt at hiding malicious intent.


And no more is to be said from me on the matter.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top