Thanks pH.
Shyrka, for some reason I didn't catch this when you posted. Did you still want feedback? If so, I think I can recall my thoughts from back in Feb.I'm not going to lie - I was a bit disappointed with my showing in this month's 300 worder.
That's because you don't have a poetical bone in your body. It's blank verse. "They have their exits and their entrances" fits the rhythm of the iambic pentameter of unstressed, stressed, unstressed, stressed (da DA da DA) etc; changing it around to "entrances and exits" mucks it all up.BTW the way, re the title, the real quote is They Have Their Exits and Entrances which I didn't realise until I looked it up. Seems odd to be that way round.
I wonder if you might know it in translation, Elckerlyc, as it's a line from Shakespeare's As You Like It, and the speech it comes from is highly appropriate for the Challenge image and mosaix's story:I really liked your story and understood what you were telling, at the end (without help of the title. The quote is unknown to me.)
I wonder if you might know it in translation, Elckerlyc, as it's a line from Shakespeare's As You Like It, and the speech it comes from is highly appropriate for the Challenge image and mosaix's story:
All the world's a stage,And all the men and women merely players;They have their exits and their entrances,And one man in his time plays many parts
Just to address the substance of my story, it is based on the common conception that people in comas may be awake on a certain level, even being able to hear conversations. The action describes how the medical team's attempt to communicate with that part of the victim's mind manifests as increasingly complex perception of the view inside a theater. She goes through color, edge perception, depth perception, converging lines perspective, motion and up and down. At that point the doctor used this channel to speak directly to her. It happens entirely in the main character's head through a stimulated visual hallucination.I found your story a bit confusing. I couldn't really follow what was going on with your protagonist. The descriptive prose too obscure. I also had trouble with the last line. Would a doctor speak like that to someone in coma? Would the patient understand while in a coma?
It is now, after careful re-readings, I think to understand you were describing an out of body experience and at the end were watching an operation-room (theater) as Dr. Myers was addressing supposedly you.
So,all in all, an interesting tale, although not really speculative in nature and too unclear in your prose with long descriptions of the 'trip' without clearly going somewhere.
Awake or aware?Just to address the substance of my story, it is based on the common conception that people in comas may be awake on a certain level, even being able to hear conversations....
OK, then, I'll try the quiz-thing:I suppose I'm still curious to know what people understood and what they didn't. I've had a while to reflect and have a fairly good idea of where I went wrong with that one but if you have the time and inclination, it would be useful.
@mosaix
I thought your story was very complex, and packed a lot into the 300 words. I did miss the boat about the story, as I thought it was about a half Martian boy (unknown father) growing up on earth trying to get back to space. I understood that he was unable to assimilate and when able to, took control of the mission.
@mosaix I see that I didn't get your story, because I didn't see James as a single minded psychopath, but an asocial, gifted, introvert individual. Even though I understood the last part, I think my mind automatically filled in that where he arrived was an extreme environment where agression, violence and even murder can easily occur, because the nature of those missions would have that. I imagined him acting along with any possible, extreme circumstances to defend himself, rather than killing everyone with no reason just to be left alone. So I wasn't afraid of James, I liked him.
mosaix -- yep, I twigged he was a grade A psychopath and that he's killed the others, though I didn't actually pick up on the clue about the book he ordered. I also didn't cotton on to the line about where he wanted to be in 25 years time and wanting to be alone. In my version he was single-minded and driven, wanting to prove everyone wrong, but then he went and killed them simply because he could, and he would now get away with it -- but your version makes a lot more sense than mine!
Your story hovered on the edges of my shortlist right up until the end, but finally got nudged off. I think part of that was the opening, as if he's a psychopath simply because he's illegitimate, so in some way his mother is to blame, which rather provoked me, and also that you're playing fast and loose with that second line in not telling us what has happened to make him be taken into care. You're right, you don't want to reveal that he's got a personality disorder quite so soon, but I think something needed to go there, even if we only suspected he was guilty on a second read, eg the family house burning down. Plus, no matter how driven to succeed, I think there would have been more pointers of his disorder, not just his cohorts believing him to be weird, which would have resulted in some question marks over his suitability which you could have arranged to be over-ridden by a higher authority. Also, the very last line didn't quite work for me, though I can't put my finger on why that is.
Overall, though, I thought the way you told it, letting us piece the story together in fragments was excellent. (The fact I've done exactly the same, complete with lots of ellipses, in this month's episode of my Storyteller serial in Kraxon has no bearing on my admiration. )
That's because you don't have a poetical bone in your body. It's blank verse. "They have their exits and their entrances" fits the rhythm of the iambic pentameter of unstressed, stressed, unstressed, stressed (da DA da DA) etc; changing it around to "entrances and exits" mucks it all up.
@mosaix
I really liked your story and understood what you were telling, at the end (without help of the title. The quote is unknown to me.) I don't think you over- or underdid the hints, the end came as a surprise and made sense, looking back.
You made it onto my shortlist, but fell just short for a vote. That was due to the somewhat messy (for lack of a better word) impression it made to me. The story consists of a lot of texts supposedly taken from reports from all kinds of sources, which you used to paint the picture, but apparently without any coherence or consistent format. It may be somewhat nitpicking, but when it comes to a vote....
Not me.Just goes to show what an active imagination us Chronners have.
Not me.
What you had written told me enough to work out what was going on... hence the vote.
Doesn’t always work in my favour when I miss the horses for the zebras.. Wow! Just goes to show what an active imagination us Chronners have.