DISCUSSION -- July 2015 300-word Writing Challenge (#18)

As a pedant, I find myself having to point out that you'd have been better using ;) rather than (or together with) :D.

;):)

:p:D Oh, I don't really have a clue what they are really supposed to mean in exactitude. As long as they sort of fit. In fact I probably attribute a good hundred different meanings to the three or four that I use. I don't think too hard about emoticon etiquette. :)
 
A really interesting month for stories.

Runners up-
Extermination- The Storyteller. Great exploration of alternate perspectives

Thank you so much for putting me so high on your list! It is always encouraging to see your name make a list, and especially when it is accompanied by a comment. :D

And your welcome for the mentions/comments for those who have said thank you. :) (Thank goodness Ursa cleared up my long list short list dilemma!)
 
Venusian Broon said:
...don't think too hard about emoticon etiquette.

Amen to that.
 
Once again there were very good pieces. It was very tough to cut down the list, as always.
Full disclaimer: I must say that there was one particular story that had me so completely lost that I couldn't consider it in voting or mentioning--and not because of quality, but simply because I can't tell if it's a masterpiece or ramblings of a fairly large commune of madmen and 2 screaming macaques flinging faeces. I'm looking at you, A. Fare Wells :D. Am I too dense to get it? It's very likely. Sorry.

Anyhooo, here are my favourites and my votes:

--CC (On the Tempting of a Practitioner of Social Engineering...): It is rather... uncommon, and not easily digested on the first read (or the second, I must admit). This one was such an intricate piece for me that I feel the need to expand: The overwhelming form clashes with the underwhelming (or is it?) conclusion for some delightful sparks that set ablaze the arrogance of science with the tinder of levelheaded hope and unbreaking human spirit (with a hint of very dry and subtle humour maybe?). A game of contrasts at all levels and a very passive-aggressive read. My 4th vote would've gone to this one on style alone.

--Alchemist (What's More Fearsome Than A Snufflemagoo?): Fell in love with it the moment I read it. If I only had one vote to give, it would be for this one. The kiddy-storytelley vibe is done superbly well and the ending blooms just right.

--Void (MMPORG): it touched a tender spot in my heart for all things gaming.

--Victoria Silverwolf (Pipe Dreams): its weirdness was intensified by the writing style, which gave a sparkly dreaminess to the whole thing.

--DG Jones (Roots): took me a while to understand what was going on. Loved it more for it. The ambience is very well set.

--Phyrebrat (What Little Girls Are Made Of): This one is all about the ending. IMO, the best finish of the month, tied with Ursa's.

--Sancho (Saint Peter of Tau Ceti e): this felt to me like the framework for a whole book-worth of fleshy SF. Get on it!

--TDZ (Budding Enterprise): grim context; a very uplifting end. Some environmentalists would outright shed tears with the beauty of this piece (my own lower lip might or might not have quivered ever so slightly ;)).

--Ursa Major (Decision Tree): hit me out of nowhere. I sense mister Ursa has a flair for dramatic last-minute entrances, rolling under the stone door, grabbing his fallen adventuring hat just before it closes. Anyway, I'm a sucker for this kind of SF. The ending was brilliant (for the story but also for the contest as a whole--a good last story).
 
You're looking at me, Ihe? All I can say right now is, Don't look at me! (I must say, however, it makes me chuckle to make your disclaimer, which in its own strange and diabolical way is kind of a mention).

It sort of is, yes. Good, bad, or undecided, any publicity is good publicity, or so I hear ;).
 
--Sancho (Saint Peter of Tau Ceti e): this felt to me like the framework for a whole book-worth of fleshy SF. Get on it!

Thanks for the mention Ihe. Glad you liked it.
Once I manage to track down that darn time thief, I will start cranking out the full version :rolleyes:
 
Wow, a vote! :) Thank you so much, A. Fare Wells!

And Ihe, your remarkably kind words on my story made my day! You were spot on in your thoughts, especially this:

(with a hint of very dry and subtle humour maybe?)

The story is not meant to be taken seriously. Thanks so much for reading it twice! :) CC
 
First up, I thought this an exceptional month. I found it very hard to exclude any story, but I had to do it. Hence the long list. So, in order of my reading, * is on the shortlist and ** gets a vote!

Remedy – Charlie* : any story that makes The Prodigy songs stay in my head is a winner anyway, but this great story reminded me of Heroes before it went bad, or the backstory of one of the X-Men. And it was so much more than that…

Glen – kansa

Phyrebrat – What Little Girls Are Made Of** : Stephen King meets Twilight Zone meets a story of grief and family. This had my vote from first reading. I’ll stop voting for Phyrebrat soon…

Venusian Broon – A lifting of the veil

The Storyteller - Extermination

Mr Orange – herba ferrocia

TitaniumTi – Grandma got run over by an alien #

Cat’s Cradle - On the Tempting of a Practitioner of Social Engineering, and His Response to Same (An Exercise in Excess)

Juliana – Dragon Bones

Ihe – Escape out of Steelbark

Cascade – They Don’t Grow on Trees…** : the idea was so bizarre it had me smiling all the way. Add that to excellent writing and it had my vote

Willwallace – Journey’s End

Victoria Silverwolf – Pipe Dreams** : I don’t read much magical realism, but when I do I like it in 300 word doses! This was a story written by someone so comfortable with the genre that she wears it like a snuggly blanket on a cold winter night. I just read it, thinking “****, this is good.”

Jo Zebedee – Le Scorpion

The Judge – The Silver Sweetbriar*: TJ is back (Welcome back, TJ!) with the artisanal (may not be a word) skills to match her silversmith. A lovely fable, well told.
Fitzchiv - Guilt

Ursa Major – Decision tree



# my title, and I like it
 
thanks for the favourite listing droflet, the big pip jo zebedee (fourth place on your list is a good placing indeed), the listings titanium ti, kerrybuchanan, the storyteller, and alchemist

and thanks to anyone that i missed who mentioned, listed, thought about listing or just liked my story. i'm off to read over the entries and maybe vote if i have time
 
Loved the variety, the depth, the breadth and the humour of this month's amazing stories. Please find my shortlist and my *votes below:

Juliana - Dragon Bones I like the way this story captures the fall into temptation that Jebb's desperation to succeed brought about.

Victoria Silverwolf - Pipe Dreams, I really enjoyed Miklos, apparent King of the underground, even better than super mario :lol:

*The Judge - The Silver Sweetbriar - I love the brilliantine simplicity of this parable that shows the tarnished depths to which even the creator can fall.

*Ursa Major - Decision Tree - Excellent deadly alien ending. I love that the difference between hope and dispair is the letter F

*Void - MMORPG Striking images and nice word play makes this story a startling experience

Phybrebrat -What little girls are made of - The scariest thing is how closely I can relate to this
 
Lots of great stories to choose from this month, and it was a tough decision. I had five to choose from and four of them I had to toss in the air and see which ones hit the ground first.

My votes went to:
Alc - because it was so much fun to read.
Remedy - because it was a great story and I want to know how he gets out of it.
Phyrebrat - because my note written down for is one is 'Excellent!'

Just missing by getting snagged in some bushes when I threw em all into the air are:
HazelRah - because I love the idea, and the line about him taking food from his mouth pouches!
TJ - because this little tale had so much packed into so little, and similarly to Phyre's my only note for this is 'Brilliant!'


Other mentions will go to:
CC - I loved the 19th century feel to the language and style.
Juliana - simply a great story.
Cascade - such a strange idea, and well executed.
Holland - I loved the rhythm and the powerful repetitions.
Void - I could really see the scenes, great descriptions.
DG - I loved the world and the language styles.
Sancho - I smell a novel in there! ;)
 
It seems the more votes available for a challenge, the harder it is for me to whittle the choices down for some reason. I easily could have used five votes for this one. Anyway, stories I liked but didn't quite make it to a vote-

Ashleyne B. Watts, The Pipes, The Pipes
Juliana, Dragon's Bones
Hazelrah, The General's Plan
Victoria Silverwolf, Pipe Dreams
Remedy, Charlie
Brian Rogers, Crew Members
The Storyteller, Extermination
Mosaix, Moving On...
Tim James, Ashes to the Winds

Votegetters-

alchemist, What's More Fearsome Than A Snufflemagoo? Clever is too weak a word to describe the style and substance of this wonderful piece of writing.

JoanDrake, The Copper Snakes. I would love to see this Festival on my local cable network.

Mr. Orange, herba ferrocia. Silly humans, our curiosity always gets the better of us.
 

Back
Top