j d worthington
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- May 9, 2006
- Messages
- 13,889
My mission, if I choose to accept it (damn, I have to!) is to read Jane Eyre in a weekend!
Oh, what an awful thing to do to a good book! Have you no shame, Newt?
Ravenus: I read Legion a very long time ago, along with a re-read of The Exorcist (since it had been close to 20 years since I'd read that one).... My feeling is that it isn't a sequel in the usual sense of the word, though it does have strong ties to the original. Both are examinations of the nature of evil, though, and show changes in Blatty's own views as he has pondered this question over the years. I think it falters as being a bit too simplistic, but it does give the book a bit more depth because it does reflect his honest concerns about things, so he's put a fair amount of himself into it; and as a novel, while flawed, it is well worth reading, I think.
On comparing to The Exorcist... I think that the earlier novel used a more varied style, from a near prose-poetic to very gritty and choppy style, whereas this one pretty much maintains a single tone and approach. And on the film... I've always rather liked Exorcist III... it's a complete failure as a horror film, but Blatty never intended it for that; rather as a film about this issues, presented in an exchatolotical suspense-thriller format; it wobbles, but it's got a lot to recommend it as long as it isn't viewed as a horror film. (I love the dialogue about the fish in the bathtub, I must admit.... )