DISCUSSION THREAD -- November 75-word challenge

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, you'd normally be right about that, except under the subgenre of Steampunk. It tends not to have the rebellion that Cyberpunk and its ilk tend to have. It simply seems to mean steam power level of technology while everything else is generally medieval level.
 
TDZ - I think I went mad shortly after reading the challenge!

...i think it's interesting how much discussion '...what is Tudor?' has sparked; yet '...what is punk?' - which can be so many things to so many people - still seems to be up for the asking...!;)

Ha! I haven't gotten that far yet. :D
 
Well, you'd normally be right about that, except under the subgenre of Steampunk. It tends not to have the rebellion that Cyberpunk and its ilk tend to have. It simply seems to mean steam power level of technology while everything else is generally medieval level.
you cant disagree with me and then say what I said.
 
Aber – There is an awful lot of truth hidden in this tale, with a perfect offhand reference that really gives it a left-tangent. That the court planned for the succession behind Elizabeth I is a matter of record, although I’m not sure how many perpetual motion devices were in use. (Of course the fact that John Dee existed and was an inventor amongst other things grounds it more)

Prizzley – One of the things I really liked about this was the effortless way it made me smile by the end of it. Here we see James become King of England as well as Scotland but a lot sooner than our history would allow. The Scottish tropes making their way South as the monarchy stabilizes is brilliant.

TSP – I could almost see this one as the adventures of Li’l Guy. I just loved the implication of a young Guy Fawkes wreaking havoc throughout his youth, even better that is ranks involved explosions of some kind is the perfect foreshadowing of his later uhhh career choice.

Amberwaves – Simple and we’re told it is not a real entry, but it works all the same especially when you take into account the general reaction to the challenge this month.

BigJ – Living in the past, especially at the time of the Black Death must have been a terrifying experience. Having no understanding where the death was coming from or how it could strike made it a supernatural experience, so imagine how much worse it could have been if the dead came back afterwards, whether as part of the plague or something else. In a few short words we get the feel of a full on zombie apocalypse, the destruction of the world as they advance.
 
Thanks for the review, Perp. :)

I don't normally believe in explaining stories, but this one has a personal attachment for me, so after the challenge is finished and all voting is concluded, I may offer up the background.
 
Never say never, Karn. There's still eleven days to be struck by inspiration. I haven't even stopped to try and think of something yet, but I will enter!
 
Never say never, Karn. There's still eleven days to be struck by inspiration. I haven't even stopped to try and think of something yet, but I will enter!

Me too -- but I don't like that whole "eleven days" thing you did, there. And aren't you supposed to be writing a novel, anyway?
 
Okay, don't hold your breath waiting for an entry by me, because I'm definitely not doing this month. I was playing with the idea to try to put one in after all, but, no.

It's the taking part that counts.

Other than bash HB :eek: I've no idea what to do with this months theme. I'm way off the brief, but I don't care because zombies are growing on me. If I'd remembered to give them RAY GUNS then I suspect I'd have hit the brief.

So I'm 100% sure this is poor advice, not to be listened to ever - just put a zombie in, you'll be fine... :p
 
Lucky Lola – There, that is the problem, sometimes people just lose too many words when trying to cut back and we end up with a story with so many gaps in it, it looks like burned parchment... uh, hold on a moment... A glimpse of the past that might have been, wonders crushed under Cromwell’s boot. Mechanical fireflies that will never see the light of day, who knows it might be history.

TacticalLoco – Sometimes it is wise to remember that a lot of burnings came from fear, fear of those who did not understand. This does not excuse it, just offers an explanation, because let’s face it burning alive is not a nice thing. Of course there is always the chance that those close-minded idiots might start turning on someone they really don’t understand, not realising that their victim understands a lot more than they, and their own actions might work against them.

Perp – I’m not sure what to say about mine this month instead of my normal offhand remark. I was caught out a bit by the challenge, to start with it looked incredibly... challenging but that changed and I found myself buried under ideas, and could not get any to work, because I was having more every time I started a story (some of them would not have worked, but it is the biggest trigger of the imagination I have had in a long time, so a genuine thanks to HB I guess. In the end I felt that this worked for me, I’m not really expecting anyone to get it (although some might), and the explanations can wait until the voting t’is done. I also cannot explain why I did poetry (or my approximation of it.) Meh.

kshRox –This one pulled up such a strong image for me that I just had to like it, one of those stories that conveys so much with so few words. A mechanical man facing a metallic queen; a genuine gut reaction of trying to hold everything in, to hide one’s emotions, and the inevitable reaction under to much pressure, and a a nice bit of humour to end it.

Bowler – Although ‘throwing a few zombies in’ might make a great story, it might not make it work, but this one does superbly. There is a logic to the tale that fits not only with the time, desperate people trying desperate things to avoid the plague, and then having to deal with the consequences. I particularly liked the end where the wise woman hot her just desserts – and the life lesson that even if you remove the cause you don’t always cure the problem.
 
Right. There we go...peasants and dragons and a bailiff and a pheonix...I think that counts as tudorpunk? maybe? I have no idea. I think the dragon makes it punk maybe...or the fact that it was...ummm? I probably should have named it "Punk the magic dragon" or somesuch...ah well...hope it at least gets a "woo! dragons!" response!
 
Woo! Dragons! :)

Quite a wide variety of entries I think. And I have no idea what I'll read each time I check back in which makes for an interesting month.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top