DISCUSSION THREAD -- November 75-word challenge

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh it was very close for me this month with Alchemist and Scott delivering great entries, but there were two others that really fired me up, HareBrain's, which had me shaken and slightly stirred - Lighting a Potato indeed (Reminded me of the Bob Newhart spoof) and my vote winner, Springs - Just a beautiful conversation. Loved it.
 
Let’s see if my second attempt of shortlisting and thanks is a little more successful.

As each month’s challenge progresses, the theme (and genre, in this case) seem to become more crystallised. When the challenge was first posted I was dumbfounded but can say now that after reading everyone’s entries I completely ‘get’ Tudorpunk and look forward to seeing it feature on QI sometime soon :D

First off I want to thank everyone who shortlisted me – it’s really nice to see your name in someone’s list, even if it doesn’t lead to a vote. And speaking of votes, thank you to Bowler1, Interversus and Starbeast (and thanks Starbeast for the font colour)

Here (in order of posting) are my shortlistings. Perhaps I have been a bit lenient in cases which may or may not have drifted slightly from the Tudor period. As long as the Tudor ‘spirit’ was evident, I was happy.

So:

StormcrowRotten Luck for a time-traveller. The image of John Lydon – always one for a bon (or, rather – if his recent appearance on Question Time is anything to go by – misplaced) mot – at the stake is a striking one. And a punful play on the ‘punk’ in Tudorpunk.

TSPNovember 5, 1580. For Edward’s internal voice, the saltpetre mix and the last line.

Lucky_Lola - From the Immolating Diary of Inigo Jones. For a cleverly constructed visual treat and the lasting image of what clockwork fireflies may look like.

Bowler1Wise Woman – A confession; I have to admit that zombies (along with ‘sexy vampires’ bore me to tears…as far as I am concerned modern vampires start and end with ‘Salem’s Lot. However your story completely caught my imagination. I'm particularly horrified by the Black Death and the thought of Olde Worlde zombies coupled with that plague is a really evocative image; not least how they came about. There is so much I like about this and that is why it got my vote. Lock up your dead – what a chilling spin on something already chilling…

StilearningBurning Roses. I don’t really know how to break down why I liked this but I think it is because of the sense of dysfunction of the factions. The whole feel of it appealed to me and the inclusion of ‘nuclear’ in the last line was the final nail.

ChrispenycateMight Plymouth Sound? My vote was tied between this and Bowler1’s. Apart from awe at the meter, content, humour and authenticity (and the ‘exeunt’ which I loved), I think I felt a deep sense of envy at your skills of verse. Of all your verses this has been my favourite. In the end I decided I had to give my vote to someone who managed to sell zombies to me :eek:


AlchemistA Cunning Plan. Another great Blackadder/Baldrick reference. The concept of a Tudornet is a great one, and the last two lines came out of nowhere which made me start, and laugh.

MosaixBut I Have The Hearth and Stomach of a… Genius. Our Lizzy is not the only Lizzy! I remember when David Icke made those claims I was astounded that anyone could be that cuh-wazy. I just liked the whole idea of this and the end visual is great.

ParsonSaved from the Fire. A nice take on our nursery rhymes and the side references are really clever.

HareBrainDoublet Oh Seven. I don’t know if I can add to what has been said here about this naughty little piece. You’re just too d*** clever!;)

James CooteThe New World. For originality and the (once again) striking visual of the colours and floating islands. Loved the name, too: Cortezia (although, was I the only one who at first read it as ‘Cortexiphan’? Must have been something to do with the idea of travelling portals) So different from the rest of our offerings.

pH
 
Thankyou Tactical Loco, Perp, stormcrow, alchemist and Ursa for the mentions/short-listings.

Some fun, interesting entries this month.

Two entries stand out for me. Ursa, the way that you can so cleverly twist and contort so many puns into your entries never ceases to amaze me; you are the Humphrey Appleby of puns, and there's no higher praise I can give!

However the winning entry is Harebrain; the idea of transporting 007 back to the 16th Century and brilliantly exectued. I would love to see the movie of this!
 
Woo-ya!:D

HareBrain - Thanks You for your vote! Made my day - especially as it was your challenge!

Phyrebrat - Thanks for the shortlisting and comments:) Much appreciated!

Bowler1 - nice jig!
 
Goodness, I go away for a day and come back to shortlistings! My humble thanks (and the offer of one of my coffee-nut muffins) go to Juliana, HB, Moonbat and Phyrebrat for the shortlistings. After a terrible couple of weeks, it's a real lift to the spirit to see one's name in others posts.

And Your Honour, you are most welcome!
 
Phyrebrat -- I am so pleased to be considered "clever" The short listing was very appreciated. Thanks!!
 
Thank you, Gary :)

(I think I need to go and lie down now. Deep breaths.)
 
Hex - nice cup of valerian tea?

* looks for cup-sized box *
 
Last edited:
That would be lovely, stormcrow. Eight sugars, please. And a little brandy.
 
Keep of the hard stuff, please: there's a tie to break.







.
 
Last edited:
Sorry. Yeah...er... aha!

* finds another box for TDZ*



Congratulations to you both!

my vote (again) to Hex.
 
Last edited:
And after a long cogitation, I've gone for TDZ for ascending the brightest heaven of invention! (And for the shameless name-dropping and making me think what happened in 2435.)

Thanks, TJ! Err ... did you find anything? :D

Hex and I are going off on a drinking binge now -- call us when it's December.
 
Many thanks for the mentions guys and many many thanks Kylara for the vote!

You're welcome Aun Doorback.

And speaking of votes, thank you to Bowler1, Interversus and Starbeast (and thanks Starbeast for the font colour)

You're welcome. I wanted to highlight my vote, and I thought pink would be nice.

And here is that tiebreaker poll

I had a strong feeling there'd be a tie. :) Time to vote again.
 
Heh, just checked the tiebreaker poll, and it's neck and neck. Trouble is I can see why, I can't seem to separate them, like the stones that make pyramids I can't get a sheet of paper between them.

It might have to come down to the roll of a dice...
 
Congrats Hex and TDZ! Both very worthy tiebreakers. Hex's was on my shorter list, so that's an easy decision, but TDZ's is marvellously inventive.
 
Neck and neck in the tie breaker, good luck to you both. I went for TDZ, but I liked both - and yes, I have a splinter from that fence I was sitting on...
 
Originally posted by chopper's pilled-up inner monologue
bah. invent a new genre out of whole cloth, get bullied into posting an example, and does anybody give you any credit for it? eh? it's like that time when you came fourth in the chopper lookeylikey competition in Whitby! except with a lower bodycount!

Ahem. :p

More seriously, a damn good challenge - well done to everybody for their interpretations of Tudorpunk, all of which are correct! And congrats to Hex & TDZ too - worthy tie-break finalists!

Now... back to that Epic Sequel that's still bothering me....
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top