DISCUSSION -- January 2015 75 Word Writing Challenge

Really great stories and very hard to choose.

To this point I have narrowed it down to a short list of 4.

The Three Suitors- Victoria Silverwolf
This is a deceptively simple story but in 75 words, Victoria subverts the paradigm of the woman in search of a husband, the paradigm of the fairytale queen and the dominant paradigm of the polygamous marriage. Further where many of us have given our protagonists an either or choice, Victoria's queen faced when with three choices fashioned two more and chose the one of the five that best suited her. This is a feminist parable. :D

A Love as White as Snow- Ursa Major
Ursa goes all 'Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are dead', on Snow White. A great idea and so well executed, that I didn't even need the hint of the title to know what story we were getting a new perspective on.

Self(ish) Preservation- Moonbat
There were some really powerful stories in this challenge but this one stuck out for me. I think for a couple of reasons. One is that it is not immediately apparent what is happening the fact that both wife and child are female and we are hence talking about life 'without her' in both sentences took me a few readings to work through, and then when I did the story hit me between the eyes. The second thing I love, is the understatement, it is natural and matter of fact, as matter of fact as the decision that the protagonist eventually makes.

Saturday Afternoon at Bonnie's- Juliana
I actually have trouble expressing what I liked about this, the ending twist, genuinely surprised me, but it was more than that. It used one sided dialogue to fit as much into it's 75 words as possible, but it was more than that too, in an absurd way (and with a twist) it was every couple, in every long term relationship, compromising and coming to an understanding about how to spend a Saturday afternoon.

Still to choose my winner.
 
Last edited:
Boy, that was a tough one. Almost had to make a database to work out which to vote for. My vote went to Alchemist for making me laugh afresh each time I read it.

Then there was a long list and shortlist*:

Ratsy
Juliana*
Karn
Culhwch
Crystal Haven*
Moonbat
D G Jones
reiver33*
Mr Orange
Bowler1*
Mosaix
The Judge* who almost won my vote, but Alc pipped you at the post, sorry.
 
A quick dash to get the last few comments in and then off I go to read through the entries and make a decision.

TJ
– Possibly the Toy Story of the literary world as the books come alive when no one is watching, only in this instance it might be poorly written slush pile fiction. It does not matter though, the anthropomorphic antics of the books provides a strange insight into what is going on between their pages and just how wide romance might be.


StilLearning – An excellent story that shows yet another aspect of love, how something so devoted as love to a ‘father’ can cause the most unexpected of decisions. In realizing that the monkey things might be as entwined in strict rules, much as she had, she makes the choice to offer them a choice. Thus not only gaining her freedom but theirs as well – no matter how dark that choice might ultimately be.


TDZ – Oh dear. Young love. Lust. Whatever. Something that is well caught here. The whole idea of notes being passed around and the consequences of such throws the reader back to another time and place. It could well be a snapshot of li9fe, you can almost breath the excitement of the girls, the note and the fall at the end. It almost makes you want to see more, to know all the ins and outs of the story.
 
I don't usually shortlist, but this time I thought there were a number of worthy stories, and wanted my faves to know they impressed. Cascade and Victoria Silverwolf were my runners-up to reiver33, partly because I loved the title.
 
I was rather scared (for myself) when I saw the choice for this month's genre but it has brought out some real gems! Not a mass of names for me this time as some didn't fit the theme of choice for me - perhaps I was missing something though - and moreover, the ones I liked, I really liked which made it much easier. Not so with my finalists, which gave me megrims if not migraines...

Shortlist
Springs
Willwallace
Victoria Silverwold
ratsy
Alc


Finalists
Bob Senior - I really loved the Twilight Zone-esque feel to this and the punchline was a great one, giving a startling mental picture!
Culhwch - Such a beautiful tale of the commonality between us no matter how different our cultural capital.
Robert MacKay - A very clever and nerdy take on the theme, with a beautiful image in the line of the comet's tail. I liked the cynical but true soup reference, too!
Reiver33 – Once again you're in my final list! You always create such original tales which result in such a visceral response for me. I was really sad reading this one, especially as I couldn't stop thinking how I'd feel if it had been Moya from Farscape that suffered this fate.
TJ - Genius composition and great wit as usual, with an almost architectural skill in the zeitgeist-y, iconic names of the books and their comments.

Vote
Culhwch - I love me some misery but I couldn't pass up on the hope in your tale, so my vote goes here.

And while I have your attention; can I make a cheap plug for the Secret Santa Guessing Thread? Take a look at the excerpts in the thread and see if you can identify who wrote what. :)

pH
 
Hi
Some really good entries this month. My shortlist is:
Springs -Call of the north
Cascade - Sunday 3am
Ratsy - True Love
Culhwch -Miene Liebe
Moonbat -Self(ish) preservation
Riever33 - And none shall weep
Perp - The greatest Love
Jastius - My best friend's wedding

My vote goes to Jastius, my best friend's wedding. I liked the way that you took what started as a conventionally set love story, with all of the passion and the strife. Yet it was the twist of the unexpected groom and a killer last line that sealed it for me
 

Back
Top